A week ago I did an article the top 20 coaches in college football history, today I am doing the most overrated. Now let me say up front these coaches are all very good at coaching football, but this list is for good coaches that get rated as great coaches when the accomplishments don’t match the myth of the coaching abilities they possess.
9) Tommy Tuberville
The amazing love and devotion so many people have for Tommy Tuberville is a mystery to me.
Regardless of where he has coached, be it Mississippi, Auburn, Texas Tech or Cincinnati his current team, success has been a relative term.
By far his best performance was at Auburn, where he won just one conference title in ten seasons. Winning bowl games is great, but how many SEC teams are really shooting for a Citrus Bowl berth when the season begins?After a massively disappointing 5-7 2008 season at Auburn, Tuberville resigned to take some time off.
He resurfaced at Texas Tech in 2010 in the wake of the Mike Leach saga, and was a .500 coach. Now he is the coach at the University of Cincinnati and has been mildly successful, coaching in a lesser conference maybe he can win eight games a season and keep his job.
8) Lloyd Carr
Lloyd Carr is by no means a bad coach, and his interviews (especially on-field interviews) are the stuff of legends.
But for all of the praise poured on Carr at Michigan, you would have thought he never lost a game.The fact of the matter is that Carr lost plenty of games, including to one Appalachian State in what was supposed to be his grand national championship send-off season.
Carr coached Michigan for 13 seasons, far fewer than so many other coaches of legendary status, and posted a record of 122-40 with five Big Ten titles (just two outright), and one national co-championship (shared with Nebraska).
Carr also posted a 5-7 bowl record, including a 1-3 mark in BCS bowls and a 1-4 mark in the all-important Rose Bowl.
7) Charlie Weis
Charlie Weis is probably one of the most disappointing coaches in the history of college sports.
Touted as an offensive genius, Weis was plucked from the New England Patriots to take over a Notre Dame program in desperate need of some success.
At first, things seemed to be headed in the right direction. Weis led the Fighting Irish to a pair of BCS bowls in his first two seasons in South Bend (both losses).Then, things started to go south.
Over the next three seasons, Weis was a combined 16-21 before finally being fired after a 35-27 record over five seasons.
After licking his wounds for a season, Weis was picked up by Will Muschamp to take over as offensive coordinator for the Florida Gators in 2011.
Despite Florida’s less-than-successful campaign, Weis was hired as the new head coach at Kansas, taking over in time for the 2012 recruiting cycle. At Kansa Weis lasted two year and went 4-20 before being fired, so much for the genuis.
6) R.C. Slocum
The story of R.C. Slocum at Texas A&M is the classic story of almost, but not quite.Those four words probably sum up his coaching career best, as the Aggies were never quite able to reach a truly lofty national level under Slocum.
Despite three straight SWC titles from 1991 to 1993, the Aggies lost each successive Cotton Bowl, and never finished higher than No. 7 in the final AP Poll.
In all, Slocum’s Aggies were just 3-8 in bowl games during Slocum’s 14 season career.
The Aggies won just one Big 12 title after the conference reinvention in 1996, but again failed to win the resulting BCS 1999 Sugar Bowl invite.
5) Gene Stallings
First, despite his great win percentage at Alabama, he was just 97-61-2 when his Texas A&M record (27-45-1) is taken into account.
Secondly, even his years at Alabama (70-16-1) were marked by controversy, as his official record is actually 62-24-0, after the Tide were forced to forfeit (not vacate) eight games from the 1993 season after it was discovered that an Alabama player was ineligible because he had signed with a professional agent.
Stallings was implicated in the ensuing NCAA investigation, and the team was placed on probation which included forfeiting 30 scholarships. The team did not fully recover until Nick Saban arrived on campus.
4) Johnny Majors
For a big name coach who led a couple of big time programs, Johnny Majors has a surprisingly average record.
Majors got his start at Iowa State before moving to Pitt, where he guided the Panthers to the 1976 national championship.
After that season, he headed to Tennessee, where he helped rebuild that program into an SEC contender, eventually winning three conference crowns before heading back to Pittsburgh.
Funny enough, if you take away his national championship year and his three SEC title seasons, the rest of his 29-year coaching career doesn’t look so great.
His final record of 185-137-10 tells much of the story, and it’s likely the only reason he’s revered so at Pitt and Tennessee is the few fleeting moments of glory to which he’s attached.
In the end Majors did a great job of getting programs turned around, his shortcoming was his lack to keep the programs he coached at the top for an extended period of time.
3) Vince Dooley
After coaching at Georgia for 25 seasons, a quick glance at Vince Dooley’s record shows us two things.
One, under Dooley, UGA won a national championship for the 1980 season.
Two, there were an awful lot of awful seasons mixed in there.
Other than the 1980-1984 span, UGA finished ranked in the final AP Top 25 in back-to-back seasons just once (1975-1976) before Dooley’s final two seasons.
And while Dooley’s teams won at least a share of six SEC titles during his tenure, his teams also finished between fourth-or-worse ten times sprinkled across his career.
A national championship is nice, but sustained success over the long haul is even better. Dooley was an ordinary coach, a good thing a man named Herschel Walker came along.
2) Charles McClendon
While his 137-59-7 record looks pretty solid on the surface, scratch a little deeper and you’ll discover that all of those seasons (18) amounted to just one SEC championship (1970) and not even a whiff of a national title.
LSU’s best finish under McClendon was that 1970 SEC Championship season, when the 9-3 Tigers lost the Orange Bowl, and found themselves No. 7 in the final AP Poll.
1) Bobby Ross
Pretty much throughout his career (including his pro stints), Bobby Ross seemed to enjoy a modicum of success surrounded by seasons of mediocrity.
He began his college coaching career at The Citadel, where he was a paltry 24-31. After a few seasons as an NFL assistant, he returned to the college game, this time in the FBS with Maryland.
Ross put together his best tenure with one team, leading the Terps to three-straight ACC titles from 1983 to 1985, but he ended his stop in Maryland with a 5-5-1 record in 1986.
He was hired by ACC rival Georgia Tech, where he began with a 2-9 record in 1987 before achieving his greatest coaching success, a national championships with the Yellow Jackets in 1990.Still, Ross was just 31-26-1 in five seasons at Georgia Tech.
Ross then spent the next eight seasons as an NFL head coach before landing at Army in 2004.
After three pitiful seasons with a combined 9-25, Ross finally called it quits and retired. Ross coached over 200 college games and won exactly half.