Tom & Mike’s Dueling Round 1 NFL Mock Draft


ESPN has Mel and Todd, and we here at have Tom and Mike! This is our dueling first round NFL mock draft with each of our picks for the entire first round. Tom and I did these independent of each other and we agree on 4 picks exactly, the rest…not so much! Keep score to see who get’s the most correct come next Thursday!

1) Cleveland Browns

Tom- Myles Garrett, DE Texas A&M:  There is no question in my mind, Garrett is by far the #1 player in this draft.

Mike-Myles Garrett-DE-Texas AM: Browns take a franchise defensive player who they can build around. He will instantly make every other player on their defensive line better.

2) San Franciso 49ers

Tom- Jonathan Allen, DT Alabama:  I can’t see QB here as badly as they need one.  Shoring up defensive woes is important

Mike-Jamal Adams-S-LSU: SF has drafted heavy on the defensive line the past few years, so I think they avoid going there. QB they will look at in the later rounds or next year in free agency (i.e., Cousins,) so I believe they take the best player at a position of need which is Adams.


3) Chicago Bears
Tom- Jamal Adams, S LSU: Another QB-needy team, but taking a center-fielder that has elite traits is hard to pass.  The secondary was awful as well.

Mike-Malik Hooker-S-Ohio St: The Bears defensive backfield is dreadful, and Hooker is an elite talent who can help them immediately.


4) Jacksonville Jaguars

Tom-Mitchell Trubisky, QB North Carolina:  Tom Coughlin is in town and is not sold on Bortles.  Trubisky is raw but can develop nicely.

Mike-Leonard Fournette-RB-LSU: I am not as high on Fournette as some others are, but this is a logical landing spot for him. Jacksonville has a terrible QB and if you can’t pass you best be able to run the ball.

5) Tennessee Titans (via Rams)

Tom-Marcus Lattimore, CB Ohio State: After the release of franchise corner McCourty, this is a very logical choice

Mike-Jonathan Allen-DE-Alabama: He is the best player on the board at this time, and the Titans are giddy they get Allen at #5.

6) New York Jets

Tom-Solomon Thomas, DT/DE Stanford: With Richardson having issues and Wilkerson one foot out the door, Thomas makes Jets decision easier

Mike- OJ Howard-TE-Alabama:  Jets have a lot of young QB’s who they used high picks on currently on the roster, so I don’t think they go QB here plus next years QB class is better. OJ Howard is a weapon for any young QB, and he can replace the targets Brandon Marshall was getting.

7) LA Chargers

Tom-OJ Howard, TE Alabama:  While they can go DE here, taking Howard gives Rivers (and future QB) a phenomenal talent and Gates replacement

Mike-Marshon Lattimore-CB-Ohio St: The Chargers would love a safety, but with the top two off the board they look to improve the secondary at CB by getting the best CB in this draft.

8) Carolina Panthers

Tom–Leonard Fournette, RB LSU: Dallas disproved taking a RB early is for fools.  Fournette and Newton will cause havoc for opposing run defenses for many years

Mike–Solomon Thomas-DE-Stanford: Thomas is one of the safest picks in this draft, and the Panthers would be jumping for joy to get him at #8. They might consider RB, but with Thomas falling in their lap they can’t pass him up.

9) Cincinnati Bengals

Tom–Reuben Foster, LB, Alabama:  Foster is the best ILB in this draft.  In a division with Le’Veon Bell, this is a huge get for Cincy

Mike–Ruben Foster-LB-Alabama: The Bengals cut Ray Maualuga and need to replace him at middle linebacker, and they don’t get much better than Ruben Foster. This kid is a do-it-all linebacker who will start day one.


10) Buffalo Bills
Tom–Malik Hooker, S Ohio State:  While Buffalo can go WR here, they need a playmaking guy in the secondary.  Hooker instantly upgrades the back end.

Mike–Mike Williams-WR-Clemson: The Bills have no WR opposite Sammy Watkins, so they go to the same school they got Watkins out of to grab Mike Williams. The Bills can run it, and they have a QB in Tyrod who is decent enough, they just need weapons for him to throw to.

11) New Orleans Saints

Tom–John Ross, WR Washington:  Ross blazed the combine with a record 4.22. Brandon Cooks who?

Mike–Gareon Conley-CB-Ohio St: The Saints need to improve their defense and Conley is a CB who has all of the physical tools you want. He is a bit soft in the tackling department, but his cover skills are elite.


12) Cleveland Browns

Tom–Gareon Conley, CB Ohio State:  Rumors of Haden being traded/released still in the air, Conley will make the transition less painful.

Mike–Mitchell Turbisky-QB-North Carolina: The Browns need a quarterback. The Browns have needed a quarterback for over a decade. The Browns get their quarterback here and can bring him along slowly.


13) Arizona Cardinals

Tom–Corey Davis, WR Western Michigan:  Larry Fitzgerald is almost finished with HOF career, bring in someone with comparable metrics.

Mike–Deshaun Watson-QB-Clemson: Carson Palmer isn’t getting any younger, and this team needs a QB of the future. When healthy this team is talented still; time to think big-picture and go QB here.


14) Philadelphia Eagles

Tom–Dalvin Cook, RB Florida State:  Wentz needs less pressure and more weapons, Cook will provide all that and then some.  Dynamic playmaking ability

Mike–Tre’Davious White-CB-LSU: He is the next best CB on the board, and the Eagles secondary needs help badly.


15) Indianapolis Colts

Tom–Forrest Lamp, OG Western Kentucky:  Joe Philbin is OL coach, Luck was destroyed last season, he needs protection.  Lamp can even play LT.

Mike–Derek Barnett-DE-Tennessee: The Colts need to get better on both sides of the line of scrimmage. They could consider offensive line here, but I think they take Barnett to get that edge rusher they lack.


16) Baltimore Ravens

Tom–Hasson Reddick, OLB Temple:  Reddick came on late and had impressive numbers.  Ravens find a replacement for an aging Suggs in the near future.

Mike–Corey Davis-WR-Western Michigan: The Ravens need to replace Steve Smith, and you don’t want Mike Wallace as your #1 WR as that is a bad situation. Davis gives Flacco another weapon in the passing game.


17) Washington Redskins
Tom-Christian McCafrey, RB Stanford: The least productive position was RB for Skins.  That changes with McCafrey and his versatility.

Mike–Haason Reddick-LB-Temple: Reddick won the underwear Olympics this past year and put on a show at the combine. He can play OLB, MLB, or possibly DE. The Redskins need help on defense making stops in key moments, and Reddick will improve that unit.


18) Tennessee Titans

Tom–Taco Charlton, DE Michigan: Taco is raw, but he has significant upside.  Big need filled by Titans.

Mike–John Ross-WR-Washington: The Titans improved their secondary with their first pick now they look to improve the return game and give Mariotta a deep threat. Ross can fly and will open up the rest of the field for their other WR’s.


19) Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Tom–Malik McDowell, DT Michigan State: McDowell has skyrocketed up draft boards with his workouts and tape from last year.  Bucs get a versatile DL.

Mike–Dalvin Cook-RB-FSU: Cook and Winston are reunited in Tampa Bay. With Doug Martin’s status up in the air Cook will step in and be a day one starter.


20) Denver Broncos

Tom–Garrett Bolles, OT Utah: The Russell Okung experience was a disaster. Bolles provides blind side protection for future QB’s.

Mike–Ryan Ramczyk-OT-Wisconsin: The Broncos need help at tackle to give whoever their starting QB is a chance in hell to survive. I like Ramczyk as the best tackle on the board, and I think Denver will be happy to have him.


21) Detroit Lions

Tom–Jabirl Peppers, CB/S Michigan: Peppers is a player nobody knows what to expect.  Lions use him at safety and helps their back end of the defense.

Mike–Jabril Peppers-S-Michigan: The Lions want a linebacker but Peppers is too good to pass up here and there will be a quality LB on the board in Round 2 for them to grab. Lions keep their fans happy by keeping the Michigan product in the state.

Jabril Peppers

22) Miami Dolphins
Tom–Takkarist McKinley, DE UCLA: With a relentless  motor and need to keep getting better, a motivated McKinley is exactly what the Dolphins need for the future at the DE position

Mike–Taco Charlton-DE-Michigan: Miami has pressing needs at (in no special order) G, LB, DE, CB/S. Defensive End is the most pressing needs for this team. The four names that will pop off the board are Charles Harris Taco Charlton, Jordan Willis, and Takkarist McKinley. I think Miami can add a starting guard in rounds 2 or 3 or later but I am not sure they can find a day one impact defensive end after round 1, so we go with Taco Charlton.

23)  New York Giants

Tom–Jarrad Davis, ILB Florida: Davis is the final piece to give the Giants an elite tackler and defense.

Mike–Christian McCaffrey-RB-Standford: The Giants have zero RB’s on their roster that put the fear into any defensive coordinator. McCaffrey can do it all and would be a perfect fit for the Giants offense.

24) Oakland Raiders

Tom–Kevin King, CB Washington: King is now the best Washington CB with Sidney Jones hurt.  Great length and coverage skills.

Mike–Jarrad Davis-LB-Florida: The Raiders run defense was awful last year and Davis is a guy who can play OLB or MLB and do it all. Very smart player who will come in and make an impact instantly.


25) Houston Texans
Tom–Marlon Humphrey, CB Alabama: the loss of AJ Bouye and Jonathan Joseph getting older, Texans need to go younger. Especially in a division with Luck.

Mike–Patrick Mahomes-QB-Texas Tech: Houston is a very good team that just doesn’t have a QB. Mahomes will have a chance to come in and start from day one which is something I am not sure Watson or Turbisky will have.


26) Seattle Seahawks

Tom–Ryan Ramczyk, OT Wisconson: Russell Wilson took a beating last year, Ramczyk will help him stay upright.

Mike–Forrest Lamp-G-Western Kentucky: Lamp to Seattle is a match made in heaven. The Seahawks offensive line has been poor the past couple years, and it has hampered their running game and gotten Russel Wilson hit a lot. Lamp can play all five positions on the o-line and will help out wherever is needed.


27)  Kansas City Chiefs
Tom–Mike Williams, WR Clemson: Williams could go higher, but Chiefs get another good WR to pair with last year’s playmaker Tyreek Hill.

Mike–Joe Mixon-RB-Oklahoma: If a team and a coach aren’t afraid to take a guy with off the field issues its KC and Andy Reid. Jamal Charles is gone, and KC has just so-so guys behind him. Mixon is an every down workhorse.


Charles Harris

28) Dallas Cowboys
Tom–Charles Harris, OLB/DE Missouri: Cowboys finally get some defensive help.  Harris versatility gives Dallas options on where to play him.

Mike–Charles Harris-DE-Missouri: You can never have enough pass rushers, and Harris gives the Cowboys another guy who can bring heat vs. opposing QB’s. CB is a bigger need, but the best player on the board is Harris.


29)  Green Bay Packers

Tom–Quincy Wilson, CB Florida: Packers missed cornerback help in the NFC title game.  Wilson helps immediately.

Mike–Kevin King-CB-Washington: The Packers must improve their secondary, and I like King a little more than guys like Jackson, Wilson, and Tabor. King to GB is a nice scheme fit as well.

30)  Pittsburgh Steelers

Tom–TJ Watt, OLB Wisconsin:  Steelers need LB depth, the younger brother of JJ is very good and will be perfect in Pittsburgh

Mike–Deshone Kizer-QB-ND: Big Ben is coming to the end of the road and is already talking retirement. Kizer is a Big Ben clone in some ways and Pittsburgh taking him here gives them the luxury to bring their next QB along slowly.

31)  Atlanta Falcons

Tom–Tre’davious White, CB LSU:  Falcons blew a 25 point lead, which means they were torched in the air.  White will help shore up that problem in the secondary.

Mike–Cam Robinson-OT-Alabama: Robinson falls some, but I think lands in a perfect spot. He can play tackle or guard, and he will make the Falcons offensive line even better.


32)  New Orleans Saints (via NE)

Tom–Deshaun Watson, QB Clemson: No better QB to learn from for a year or 2 in Drew Brees.  Watson has a winning pedigree.

Mike–Jordan Willis-DE-Kansas St: It will kill Sean Payton to pass on David Njoku the TE out of Miami here as he has the potential be a superstar TE for many years,  but he has to go in a different direction as he needs to improve that defense. Jordan Willis is one of the safest draft picks in this entire draft.
Follow us on Twitter @DolphinsTalk