10). Joe Montana, San Francisco 49ers, Kansas City Chiefs
Only played first few years of the decade, but had an excellent 1990 season for the 49ers and then led the Chiefs to the playoffs including an AFC Championship game.
9). Drew Bledsoe, New England Patriots
He will go down in history as the man who got hurt and was replaced by Tom Brady, but Bledsoe was an excellent QB who from 1994-96 carried the Patriots on his back and got them to Super Bowl XXXI.
8). Dan Marino, Miami Dolphins
Marino after his magnificent 1984 season never won more than one playoff game in a season. The 90’s saw a significant drop-off from his production in the 1980’s. His best shot at changing the perception of his career was in 1992 when the Dolphins had the home-field advantage in a Championship game against the Bills. Marino played poorly and was blown out at home.
7). Randall Cunningham, Philadelphia Eagles, Minnesota Vikings
Cunningham was an incredible talent who at the end of his career became an excellent pocket passer. If he had played today in the more modern spread offense, Cunningham would have probably been a Hall of Famer.
6). Warren Moon, Houston Oilers, Minnesota Vikings
Moon like Marino was a fantastic regular season Quarterback who never did play as good in the post-season as he did in the regular season. The big question on Moon’s career, of course, is what he could have accomplished if his first five years of Professional Football had been played in the NFL instead of the CFL.
5). Jim Kelly, Buffalo Bills
Kelly is still the only Quarterback in history to lead his team to four straight Super Bowl appearances. He never won a Super Bowl and played poorly in three of the four, but making four straight Super Bowls is still a great accomplishment and put him ahead of the rest of these guys below him on this list.
4). Brett Favre, Green Bay Packers
This list seems filled with guys that couldn’t get the job done in the playoffs, Favre does fit in that category if you look at his whole career. In the 90’s though he did lead the Packers to Super Bowls XXXI and XXXII, winning XXXI.
3). Steve Young, San Francisco 49ers
Steve Young only won one Super Bowl in his career, but that playoff run was one of the greatest any QB has ever had. Young was a threat with his arm as well as his legs and will go down as one of the greatest Quarterbacks to ever play the game.
2). Troy Aikman, Dallas Cowboys
Aikman to me is maybe the most underrated Quarterback in NFL history; he won three Super Bowls on one of the greatest teams in NFL history. I think his biggest problem and why he is not rated very high by most was the fact that his teams were so dominant that he never had too many chances to lead his teams from behind. Technically one of the greatest Quarterbacks to ever play the game.
1). John Elway, Denver Broncos
Elway led the Broncos to three Super Bowls in the 1980’s. The teams he led had little to no running game, and he had no elite receivers, and Elway lost all three of those Super Bowl games. In the 90’s From 1993 until his retirement in 1998, Elway averaged 24 touchdowns and 12 interceptions per season and had a passer rating of 88.9 with five Pro Bowls and two Super Bowl championships.