11) 1979 Pittsburgh 27 Houston 13
This game was the last hurrah for the legendary “Steel Curtain.” The Oilers and Steelers combined to create a great rivalry between 1977-80. The Oilers were led on offense by running back Earl Campbell and on defense by Robert Brazile. The Steelers in the 1978 Championship game had blitzed the Oilers in a 34-5 game played in a freezing rain storm at Three Rivers Stadium. The 1979 game was much tighter and more memorable for a touchdown that was not allowed. Early in the 4th quarter with the Oilers trailing the Steelers 17-10, Mike Renfro caught an apparent touchdown pass in the back of the end zone that officials ruled incomplete. In 1979 there was no instant replay and the game went a long way in helping the Steelers hold off the Oilers 27-13. After the 79 season, both teams were never the same.
10) 1995 Pittsburgh 20 Indianapolis 16
The Colts had slipped into the playoffs with a 9-7 record and were missing their best player Marshall Faulk who had been injured. The Steelers were big favorites, but the game came down to one last drive. The Colts had one final chance as QB Jim Harbaugh marched his way down the field to the Pittsburgh 29-yard line with 5 seconds remaining. On the last play of the game, Harbaugh fired a Hail Mary pass, hoping for a miracle, he almost got it. The ball was tipped around and fell into the chest of Colts receiver Aaron Bailey. It looked like Bailey had caught the ball, but the ball slipped through his hands and hit the turf. The Steelers returned to the Super Bowl for the first time since 1979, and the Colts ended up being a team who just missed becoming one of the great underdog stories in NFL history.
9) 2012 New England 23 Baltimore 20
This game was a battle of a high-powered offense against a physical hard nosed defense. And it came down to that matchup, the Ravens had a 20-16 lead, but Tom Brady marched the Patriots the length of the field ending with Brady sneaking into the end zone from a yard out giving the Patriots a 23-20 lead. With time running out Ravens QB Joe Flacco led the Ravens into field goal range as time was running out. The game looked like it would go to overtime as Ravens kicker Billy Cundiff lined up to kick a 29-yard field goal. Somehow, Cundiff shanked the kick, and the Patriots had averted a sudden death overtime and advanced to yet another Super Bowl.
8) 1994 San Diego 17 Pittsburgh 13
The Steelers entered this game as huge favorites against the Chargers, who were expected by nobody to make it that far. The Steelers can out and dominated the first half of the game taking a 13-3 lead. The Chargers defense stiffened led by NFL Legend Junior Seau and shut the Steelers out the rest of the game. The Chargers took the lead for good with just over 5 minutes left when QB Stan Humphries dropped back to pass and found receiver Tony Martin, who had a step on Steelers cornerback Tim McKyer. Humphries fired a perfect pass that Martin hauled in over a leaping McKyer, giving San Diego its first lead of the game. The Steelers had one last gasp as Steeler QB Neil O’Donnell led the Steelers down the field. With the Steelers facing a fourth and goal from the 3-yard line, O’Donnell dropped back and threw a pass to Barry Foster at the goal line. Linebacker Dennis Gibson batted down the pass, and the Chargers had pulled off the upset. It would be the only time in the Chargers history that they would reach the Super Bowl.
7) 1975 Pittsburgh 16 Oakland 10
Maybe the greatest rivalry in NFL history was the Steelers vs. Raiders during the decade of the 70’s. The Violence these teams unleashed on each other was unreal, if these teams were to play today, they would probably all be suspended. The controversy was the calling card of this rivalry, and the 1975 Championship game gave us just that. The turf at Three Rivers Stadium was slick and icy, which would have seemed to be an advantage for the Steelers who won games with their defense and run game. The Raiders were a vertical passing team, and the icy field would most certainly hurt them. Al Davis even years later was convinced that the Steelers intentionally left the field uncovered to gain an advantage. The Raiders played from behind almost the entire game and trailed 16-7 in the fourth quarter. Of course, as the Raiders were known to do they made a comeback which fell just short as a Stabler to Branch pass fell complete in the end zone sending the Steelers to the Super Bowl with a 16-10 win.
6) 1972 Miami 21 Pittsburgh 17
The Miami Dolphins were the road team in this game even though they were undefeated. The NFL used to rotate which division would get to host the playoff games, so with an undefeated record, the Dolphins traveled to Pittsburgh to take on the upstart Steelers. The Steelers the week prior had beaten the Oakland Raiders 13-7 on the “Immaculate Reception”. The Steelers came out hot and immediately went up 7-0, but the Dolphins responded just before halftime to go to the locker room in a 7-7 tie. The Steelers took a brief lead of 10-7 in the third quarter, from their Dolphins coach Don Shula pulled starter Earl Morrall and put in Bob Griese, Griese had been injured early in the season. Griese came in and hit WR Paul Warfield on a big 52-yard pass which was followed by a short Jim Kiick touchdown giving the Dolphins a lead they would not relinquish. The Steelers just made to many mistakes to beat a veteran team like the Dolphins.
5) 1987 Denver 38 Cleveland 33
In a rematch of a game, we will talk about a bit later, the Broncos pounded the Browns in the first half taking a 21-3 lead. The second half was dramatic as the Browns mounted a breathtaking comeback behind QB Bernie Kosar and of course John Elway responded with a late 4th quarter TD drive giving the Broncos a 38-31 lead. Kosar led the Browns in the final minutes all the way down to the Denver 8 yard line. With the ball on the Denver 8-yard line with 1:12 remaining in the fourth quarter, it looked like the Browns were going to return the favor to Denver from the previous season. Kosar handed the ball to Byner, who seemed to have a clear path to the end zone. As Byner reached the 2-yard line, Broncos defensive back Jeremiah Castille stripped Byner of the football and recovered the fumble. Byner never saw Castille, as Slaughter missed his assignment to seal off Castille, giving Byner the hole to the end zone. NBC announcer Dick Enberg said during the broadcast: “And wasn’t it ironic that Denver got the ball back at the 2-yard line?
4) 1977 Denver 20 Oakland 17
The Broncos won they’re first ever AFC West title in 1977 and had developed a great rivalry with the Oakland Raiders. The teams split the two games played during the season with each winning on the road. The controversy was a huge part of this game. In the third quarter, the Broncos were ahead 7-3 and had a first and goal from the Oakland 2-yard line. Broncos running back Rob Lytle attempted to dive into the end zone, where he was hit by Raider safety, Jack Tatum. The ball popped loose, and the Raiders recovered the football. Or so they thought. Linesman Ed Marion blew the play dead, ruling that forward progress had been halted. Replay showed that Lytle had fumbled as soon as he was contacted, well short of the goal line. It was a huge factor in the game as it gave the Broncos a 14-3 lead. The Raiders behind QB Ken Stabler mounted their usual comeback but came up just short losing 20-17.
3) 1980 Oakland 34 San Diego 27
The Chargers were expected to win this game behind QB Dan Fouts wide open attacking offense. The Raiders were seen as a team on the decline. Early in the season the Riders had lost starting QB Dan Pastorini because of a broken leg. In stepped backup QB Jim Plunkett, Plunkett had been considered a bust in failed attempts at New England and San Fransisco. In Oakland though Plunkett reclaimed the magic he had while winning the Heisman Trophy at Stanford. The Raiders jumped out to an early 21-7 lead and never looked back. The most telling part of the game was with 6 minutes left when the Raiders started a drive clinging to a 34-27 lead. The Chargers never got the ball back as the Raiders chewed up the entire clock ending the game with a 34-27 win.
2) 2006 Indianapolis 38 New England 34
The Patriots had owned the Colts in the team’s first two playoff meetings, but this game would be very different. The first half did look like the team’s first two meeting as the Patriots jumped out to a 21-6 halftime lead. Then Peyton Manning got hot. The game was on the line with under three minutes left on the clock. This game will always be remembered for Manning leading the Colts on a drive that took very little time off the clock. Within 19 seconds, the Colts were at the New England 11-yard line, looking to take the lead. The Colts used the clock wisely, winding the clock down to exactly 1 minute remaining, before Joseph Addai ran untouched from 3 yards out, giving the Colts their first lead of the game. The Patriots had one last chance, and with Tom Brady at the helm, you just knew they would strike. However, there would be no miracle for New England. Marlin Jackon intercepted a Brady pass in Colts territory, as Indianapolis and Manning finally got the proverbial monkey off its back.
1) 1986 Denver 23 Cleveland 20 (OT)
This game is just known as “The Drive.” The Browns had taken a 20-13 lead with under 5 minutes to play. The kickoff after the Browns touchdown was mishandled leaving the Broncos at the two-yard line. Even for the master of the comeback John Elway even this task looked too daunting. The Browns helped the cause though when they decided to play a soft zone defense, allowing the Broncos to gradually move the ball down the field. With only 39 seconds remaining, Elway and Jackson teamed up on a 5-yard touchdown reception, to tie the game and force overtime. The Browns won the toss but failed to get a first down on their opening drive. They wouldn’t see the football again. Elway led the Broncos on a 60-yard drive; that was capped off by a 33-yard field goal from Rick Karlis, sending the Broncos to the Super Bowl.